Forecourt Trader - 30 years at the heart of the fuel retailing community

HMRC overturns duty deferment victory

29 July, 2016

Brobot tried to obtain duty deferment

A landmark tax verdict that would have befitted many smaller dealers in the forecourt sector has been overturned after HMRC won an appeal, but the tax expert who fought the first case believes there is still room to fight.

The case centred on a bid by former Top 50 Indie Brobot to obtain duty deferment on fuel supplies, and actions by HMRC to obstruct it.

Last September Brobot won at a tax tribunal when the judge found that HMRC had acted unreasonably, but HMRC appealed the decision.

After the first decision Brobot was taken over by fellow Top 50 Indie HKS and when the appeal was heard no one had been instructed to defend it, so HMRC’s case was not challenged.

Tax expert Alan Powell, who represented Brobot at the first hearing, said: “The tribunal finds HMRC had not acted unreasonably on the basis of the first tribunal decision which unfortunately was a bit short on facts and law. What is not mentioned is crucial.”

Powell said that HMRC argued that it would not issue a deferment account number (DAN) to Brobot because of the “risk”, and that was their entire case.

He added: “I proved there was no risk. I pressed in cross-examination and they couldn't explain why they made such an unsubstantiated assertion.”

Powell said the appeal verdict set a precedent which made challenging HMRC on the issue of duty deferment more difficult, but it may be subject to further appeal because the decision impacts adversely on other industries which have hitherto enjoyed access to full deferment.

For more detail on the case, and the potential benefits for dealers, see next week’s issue of Forecourt Trader.





  • Weekly
    Retail
  • Weekly
    wholesale
  • Daily
    Average
Weekly retail fuel prices: 2 September 2019
RegionDieselLPGSuper ULUL
East132.3563.90140.80128.93
East Midlands132.1271.23141.73128.82
London131.70142.12129.26
North East130.66140.60128.17
North West131.39140.18128.47
Northern Ireland129.03134.10126.35
Scotland131.70139.60128.79
South East132.7358.90141.28129.68
South West131.9563.90140.12128.70
Wales130.9855.70137.19127.82
West Midlands131.6066.90140.32129.05
Yorkshire & Humber131.2384.90140.57128.52

Most read

As the Government is urged to publish its plans for E10 by the All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for British Bioethanol, would you welcome the introduction of E10 as the right next step in cutting automotive carbon emissions?